This is a known issue with MsSQL since http://ofbiz.135035.n4.nabble.com/Unique-constraint-on-Person-cardId-breaks-ofbiz-on-SQL-Server-td4656840.html The problem does not exist with Derby, nor with the mostly open source DBMS used with OFBiz: Postres, MySQL, MariaDB, etc. So we will not change the current OOTB setting and suggest to simply change your own configuration Thanks: Schumann Ye for report